Anna's plan of retreat doesn't include romance, but love comes calling in 1901 Raisinville. The immigrant brings a secret to the rural Michigan parish where she takes on work as a rectory housekeeper-the abortion she chose to end a pregnancy. In her rectory refuge after the sacrifice of her child, she falls for Joe, a new priest listening with love in his voice and honor in his eyes. Taking a chance, she gives herself to him body and soul, searching for love and respect. He's exiled from priesthood for the affair-and then their love delivers a child. Married in secret, a fresh start calls Anna and Joe to Toledo-a hub of breweries, bicycle factories, and prospects for progress.

In a time when the Rust Belt sparkles, she works for better fortunes. Joe was a better priest than he is a provider, but she will improve him. She can be his church. When the child's scarlet fever shatters Anna's dream, they hunt down a cure. But Joe returns to the priesthood as part of his bargain with God. While the pain of separation slashes at her, Anna must start anew. She must discover allies and muster new courage, or lose everything she loves.