After the OSBI and Sheriff Joe solved the murder of Jenni Whittington and imprisoned her killer, Will settled into a comfortable and routine life with Jenni's two small children. While Will awaits a final adoption declaration for the children, Sheriff Joe approaches him with a request. This request will once again shatter Will's ability to live a simple life.

Despite beginning a new chapter in his life, Will is confronted with lingering ties from his past. Jake Cummings' family believe they have a score to settle and have dedicated themselves to retribution. But who will suffer the most from their evil mission, Will or someone close to him?