REAL-LIFE MURDER. REAL-LIFE MYSTERY.

It's every parent's worst nightmare when a child goes missing. October 2, 1993, Gloria Toole frantically searched for her oldest daughter when she woke up to discover her missing. Hours later, a local fisherman found Samantha Toole's lifeless body on the shoreline near her home. She was still in her pyjamas.

Who killed Samantha Toole? Was it her mother's boyfriend, George Pitt? Or was it someone else?

With the absence of physical evidence linking Pitt to the crime, the jury convicted and sentenced him to life in prison. While behind bars, a private investigation was happening in the city of Saint John, New Brunswick. The focus on who killed Samanatha.